A Funeral For Affordable Housing In Grandview

Our Community, Our Plan (OCOP) and Grandview Heritage Group (GHG) Will lead the community in a Funeral for an Affordable Rooming House: 1723 Napier (at Commercial Drive) to be demolished to make way for upscale duplex

Join Us On Sunday, September 7, 4:00-4:30pm, 1723 Napier

Neighbours & former residents invite the public and media to share memories of a disappearing East Van phenomenon: affordable housing. Dress is formal. Eulogy, speeches and funeral march.


Garth’s Eulogy

We gather to mourn the passing of 1723 Napier (1922 – 2014.) It will soon fall to the wrecker’s ball, making way for million dollar homes.

As friends and neighbours, we commemorate the life of this heritage building, which gave affordable shelter to artists and those of more modest means. Such places are of an increasingly rare breed in East Van. And so we mourn the passing of our community as well.

At times like this we take solace in scripture. John 14:2 tells us: “my father’s house has many rooms.” And so did this rooming house off Commercial Drive — seven bedrooms and two suites at about $500 each — an example of density before it was a buzzword on the tongues of City planners. The duplex that will rise in its place will have room for only two, wealthy households.

“Density,” brothers and sisters, is that fork-tongued rationale the City fathers use to justify upscale condo towers that practically reach up to Heaven itself.

But let us not remember 1723 Napier as we see it now: empty, without windows or walls; awaiting demolition. Let us remember the generations who lived, laughed, loved, created and cried there. They nestled in the embrace of beam and timber, harvested from old growth Douglas Fir — the finest lumber of its time, now all but gone. Are those faithful old timbers headed for the landfill?

It is rumored that Tommy Chong (of Cheech & Chong fame) was once a co-owner. So was Bonnie Beck-woman, who also runs a store on the Drive that exemplifies the concept of density in the sheer quantity of stock, shoehorned into every square foot.

And so, as we mourn the passing of 1723 Napier, do we also mourn the passing of our East Vancouver? Are we now seeing a new era where the City gates are only open to those who can afford the down payment?

We watch this generation of rambling houses, once sheltering many households replaced by upscale lifestyle spaces for young, upwardly mobile urban professionals.

Oh! The hubris of Man! Dwelleth close to the earth, with thy brothers! Dwell not in the sky, in cells of gold!

Woe to he who celebrates the demolition of these affordable, green, heritage homes!

Woe to he who builds not shelter for his brothers and sisters, but shelter for his investments and those of his fellow speculators.

Let us pray, yes, but let us also be angry – and may our anger be righteous!

Let them hear in City Hall not the splintering of old timbers, but this congregation’s clarion call for social justice!

Let this not be a world for the landed gentry alone, but for us all.

Ashes to ashes, sawdust to sawdust.



4 Responses to A Funeral For Affordable Housing In Grandview

  1. Tak Uyede says:

    Jak/Garth,: wish I were in town to attend but unfortunately Maryke has been in Victoria General with acute G.B.S. and cannot leave. Best regards, Tak

  2. jakking says:

    Tak: We are so sorry to hear of Maryke’s illness, and we are wishing her well. Take care.

  3. Mike Hansen says:

    ‘Let us pray’, you don’t vote in the SAME mayor & council as you’ve done for many years! ‘Dust to dust, ashes to ashes’. Don’t ‘cry over spilled milk’. Learn about who your voting for next time! Is their expertise, ‘big business’? Do they support the ‘condo-kings’? Do they base their beliefs on ‘visions’ or reality? The rich don’t know what The People want and don’t care. Vote for change.
    Vote ‘outside the box’!

  4. A Drive Flaneur says:

    Interesting to read City Hall Watch investigations into the house and seemingly finding that city zoning records are erased!!


    ….But the link on the City site is dead.


    We try the “wayback machine,” the archive.org site, but nothing turns up.

    We look at the City’s Development Permit Board, but nothing shows up for the address or DE416807 in recent years.

    So basically, information for citizens has been wiped off the public record online. One asks, what public benefit is there to making this information unavailable?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: